Skip to content
Join The Movement - Buy American
Join The Movement - Buy American

Puzzles & Brain Games | American-Made Wooden & Jigsaw Puzzles

Filters

$0
$629.50

Amish-Made Mailbox, Post Mount, Made With Weather-Proof Poly Lumber, UV-Resistant

Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50 - Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50
Current price $197.50
$197.50 - $197.50
Current price $197.50

Add a touch of country charm to your property with this poly lumber mailbox. The rustic barn-style mailbox is made by our Amish friends in Shipshew...

View full details
Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50 - Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50
Current price $197.50
$197.50 - $197.50
Current price $197.50
Save 7% Save %

Wooden Tic Tac Toe Game With 8 Wooden X and O Game Pieces, Amish Made

Original price $37.50 - Original price $37.50
Original price
$37.50
$37.50 - $37.50
Current price $37.50

Take the classic Tic Tac Toe paper game to the next level with this artfully crafted set made from solid wood by Amish folks in Shipshewana, Indian...

View full details
Original price $37.50 - Original price $37.50
Original price
$37.50
$37.50 - $37.50
Current price $37.50

Hand-Painted Barn Quilt Sign - Mariner's Compass "Sailor" Design

Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price $209.50
$194.50 - $344.50
$194.50 - $344.50
Current price $194.50

Turn your barn into a masterpiece with our hand-painted barn quilts. Our barn quilts are made for us by Gary Hershberger, an Amish craftsman from S...

View full details
Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price $209.50
$194.50 - $344.50
$194.50 - $344.50
Current price $194.50
Save up to 5% Save %

Hand-Painted Barn Quilt Sign, Dahlia "Sunburst" Design, 36" x 36"

Original price $385.50 - Original price $385.50
Original price
$385.50
$385.50 - $385.50
Current price $385.50

Turn your barn into a masterpiece with our hand-painted barn quilts. Our barn quilts are made for us by Gary Hershberger, an Amish craftsman from S...

View full details
Original price $385.50 - Original price $385.50
Original price
$385.50
$385.50 - $385.50
Current price $385.50

Hand-Painted Barn Quilt - Red Labyrinth Design - Outdoor Wall Sign

Original price $209.50 - Original price $334.50
Original price $209.50 - Original price $334.50
Original price $209.50
$194.50 - $312.50
$194.50 - $312.50
Current price $194.50

Turn your barn into a masterpiece with our hand-painted barn quilts. Our barn quilts are made for us by Gary Hershberger, an Amish craftsman from S...

View full details
Original price $209.50 - Original price $334.50
Original price $209.50 - Original price $334.50
Original price $209.50
$194.50 - $312.50
$194.50 - $312.50
Current price $194.50
Save up to 7% Save %

Rustic Flower Planter, Made from Real Wooden Whiskey Barrels, White Oak, Indoor or Outdoor

Original price $172.50 - Original price $172.50
Original price
$172.50
$172.50 - $172.50
Current price $172.50

Add a rustic touch to your lawn or patio with this wooden Barrel Planter made from a reclaimed whiskey barrel! The planters will vary slightly in s...

View full details
Original price $172.50 - Original price $172.50
Original price
$172.50
$172.50 - $172.50
Current price $172.50

Gazebo Bird Feeder - Triple Compartment, Post-Mount

Original price $337.50 - Original price $337.50
Original price
$337.50
$337.50 - $337.50
Current price $337.50

Attract songbirds of many species to your backyard with this Deluxe Gazebo Triple Hopper Bird Feeder. The lovely Gazebo Bird Feeder is our most exp...

View full details
Original price $337.50 - Original price $337.50
Original price
$337.50
$337.50 - $337.50
Current price $337.50

Multi-Wood Aggravation Marble Game Board Set, 24" Wide

Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50 - Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50
Current price $196.50
$196.50 - $196.50
Current price $196.50

Wow your friends and family with a beautiful multi-wood Wahoo Game (also called Aggravation) from AmishToyBox.com. The Deluxe Aggravation Game is m...

View full details
Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50 - Original price $212.50
Original price $212.50
Current price $196.50
$196.50 - $196.50
Current price $196.50
Save 8% Save %

Hand-Painted Barn Quilt Sign, United States Flag "Old Glory" Design

Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price
$209.50 - $364.50
$209.50 - $364.50
Current price $209.50

Turn your barn into a masterpiece with our hand-painted barn quilts. Our barn quilts are made for us by Gary Hershberger, an Amish craftsman from S...

View full details
Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price
$209.50 - $364.50
$209.50 - $364.50
Current price $209.50

Hand-Painted Barn Quilt, Mariner's Compass Golden Abyss Design

Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price
$209.50 - $364.50
$209.50 - $364.50
Current price $209.50

Turn your barn into a masterpiece with our hand-painted barn quilts. Our barn quilts are made for us by Gary Hershberger, an Amish craftsman from S...

View full details
Original price $209.50 - Original price $364.50
Original price
$209.50 - $364.50
$209.50 - $364.50
Current price $209.50

Classic Bird Feeder with Suet Holder and Peanut Feeder, Eco-Friendly Poly Lumber, Post-Mount

Original price $196.50 - Original price $196.50
Original price
$196.50
$196.50 - $196.50
Current price $196.50

Attract songbirds of many species to your backyard with our Classic Deluxe Bird Feeder. The bird feeder is crafted with durable poly "lumber" which...

View full details
Original price $196.50 - Original price $196.50
Original price
$196.50
$196.50 - $196.50
Current price $196.50

Wooden Toy Pickup Truck and Flatbed Trailer with Skidloader Set

Original price $179.50 - Original price $179.50
Original price
$179.50
$179.50 - $179.50
Current price $179.50

Wow your little boys with this unique Pickup Truck and Equipment Trailer complete with a Skidloader that fits onto the trailer. The wooden pickup t...

View full details
Original price $179.50 - Original price $179.50
Original price
$179.50
$179.50 - $179.50
Current price $179.50

Oriole Bird Feeder, Porch Jelly-Cup Oriole Feeder

Original price $27.50 - Original price $27.50
Original price
$27.50
$27.50 - $27.50
Current price $27.50

Bring your Feathered Oriole Friends in close with this Porch Oriole Jelly Feeder. It is made by Amish Craftsmen in Shipshewana, Indiana. The Oriole...

View full details
Original price $27.50 - Original price $27.50
Original price
$27.50
$27.50 - $27.50
Current price $27.50

Hanging Oriole Jelly and Orange Bird Feeder, Eco-Friendly Poly Lumber

Original price $47.50 - Original price $51.50
Original price
$47.50 - $51.50
$47.50 - $51.50
Current price $47.50

Delight your Oriole Friends with this flashy Oriole Jelly Feeder. It is made by Amish Craftsmen in Shipshewana, Indiana. The Oriole Feeder is made ...

View full details
Original price $47.50 - Original price $51.50
Original price
$47.50 - $51.50
$47.50 - $51.50
Current price $47.50

Amish-Made Butterfly House, Eco-Friendly Poly Lumber

Original price $59.50 - Original price $59.50
Original price
$59.50
$59.50 - $59.50
Current price $59.50

Invite colorful butterflies to enjoy the comforts of this cute butterfly house! This unique Amish-made butterfly house is designed to allow the but...

View full details
Original price $59.50 - Original price $59.50
Original price
$59.50
$59.50 - $59.50
Current price $59.50

American-Made Puzzles & Brain Games: Wooden & Jigsaw Collections

Puzzles are more than just a pastime; they are essential tools for cognitive development, relaxation, and focused family fun. Whether you are assembling a complex landscape with 1,000 pieces or guiding a wooden animal figure into its slot, puzzles sharpen the mind and nurture patience. At BuyAmerican.com, we believe that the components of your fun should be built with integrity and safety. Welcome to our Puzzles & Brain Games collection, where we champion American manufacturing to bring you durable, non-toxic, and engaging challenges for all ages.

The market is saturated with thin cardboard, poor quality cutting, and cheap, flimsy imported plastic. We offer a superior experience. We partner with small-batch woodworkers, ethical toy manufacturers, and domestic printers who prioritize material quality. Our puzzles feature thick, durable chipboard, solid domestic hardwoods, and non-toxic inks and finishes. Investing in an American-made puzzle means investing in safety, structural quality, and creating an heirloom activity that can be enjoyed for generations.

Jigsaw Puzzles (The Classic Challenge)

The jigsaw puzzle is the centerpiece of family downtime. Our collection features unique designs and superior component quality.

  • Thick, Durable Chipboard: Say goodbye to warped, peeling pieces. Our puzzles are printed on heavy-duty, dense chipboard. This material resists bending and breakage, ensuring the pieces snap together cleanly and last through countless assemblies.

  • Non-Toxic & Vibrant Inks: We prioritize puzzles printed with certified non-toxic, vegetable-based inks. This ensures that the beautiful images—often depicting American landscapes, historical events, or original art—remain vibrant and safe.

  • Precision Cut: The quality of the die-cut is essential for a good puzzle. Our manufacturers use high-precision steel cutting tools that ensure pieces fit together perfectly without frayed edges or confusing loose fits.

  • Unique Piece Shapes: Look for puzzles featuring "whimsical pieces" (pieces cut into the shape of animals or recognizable objects) that add an extra layer of charm and complexity to the challenge.

Wooden Puzzles & Brain Games

Wooden puzzles offer a satisfying, tactile experience and structural integrity that cardboard cannot match.

  • Heirloom Quality: These puzzles are built to last. Crafted from solid domestic hardwoods like Maple and Birch, the pieces are substantial, easy to grip, and finished with safe, natural oils.

  • 3D & Logic Puzzles: Challenge the mind with complex wooden brain teasers, interlocking puzzles, and geometric shapes. These activities require spatial reasoning, logic, and patience, making them excellent gifts for teenagers and adults.

  • Developmental Puzzles: For younger children, explore wooden peg puzzles and sound puzzles. The thick, chunky pieces are perfect for small hands learning fine motor skills, while the non-toxic paint is safe for toddlers.

Kids’ Educational Puzzles

Puzzles are a foundational tool for early education, teaching everything from the alphabet to geographical awareness.

  • Map & Geography: Learn about the states, capitals, and landmarks of the United States with large wooden floor puzzles and map sets that teach spatial relationships and memory skills.

  • Shape & Number Sorting: Simple wooden puzzles that help toddlers learn colors, numbers, and basic shapes through hands-on manipulation.

  • Artisan Quality: Unlike the cheap, thin wood sometimes used in imports, our children's puzzles are made from thick, durable wood that prevents warping and ensures the pieces can be passed down to younger siblings.

Accessories & Storage

Protect your investment and enjoy the activity.

  • Puzzle Mats & Boards: Felt-lined mats allow you to work on large puzzles without taking up permanent space on your dining table. The mat allows you to roll up the puzzle safely until you are ready to resume work.

  • Storage Boxes: Our wooden puzzles often come in sturdy wooden boxes or display trays that double as the working surface, making cleanup and storage simple and attractive.


Buying Considerations: The Quality of the Piece

When buying puzzles, the best value is found in the component quality and the safety of the materials. Here is what to look for to ensure your American-made puzzle is an enduring investment:

1. Piece Thickness and Material

  • Jigsaw: Look for puzzles where the finished piece is thick (at least 2mm or more). Thicker pieces are less likely to bend, tear, or chip when separated.

  • Wooden: Ensure it is solid wood (Maple, Birch), not particle board or a thin veneer glued to composite.

2. Non-Toxic Inks If the puzzle is painted or printed (especially for children), safety is key. Demand non-toxic, lead-free, and vegetable-based inks. Our US manufacturers are transparent about their finishes, often using low-VOC coatings that prevent harmful off-gassing.

3. The Snapping Sound A high-quality jigsaw puzzle will make a distinct "snap" or "click" when pieces fit together correctly. This is a sign of precision-cutting and quality chipboard density. Puzzles with loose fits or pieces that peel are signs of a poor-quality, usually imported, product.

4. Longevity and Archival Quality If you plan to frame a finished puzzle or keep it as a collectible, ensure the components are made with archival, acid-free paper and inks. This prevents the image from yellowing or becoming brittle over time.

5. Age-Appropriateness The number of pieces determines the difficulty, but the size of the piece determines safety. For infants and toddlers, choose large, chunky wooden pieces that pose no choking hazard. For adults, look for piece counts between 500 and 1000 for a satisfying challenge.