Skip to content

GET UPDATES ON AMERICAN-MADE PRODUCTS & NEW DROPS

Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce
Elijah's Xtreme

Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce

$14.00 $14.00 Sale
Quantity
American Made Guarantee
Ships From the USA
Supports American Business
Shipping & returns

Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.

Why American-made

Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.

Xtreme Regret is a Carolina Reaper hot sauce that earns its name — the instant-regret heat without losing the flavor.

Xtreme Regret Hot Sauce hits an estimated ~800,000 SHU* from a 50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion. This is a serious carolina reaper sauce — fiery and pepper-forward — that has earned 9 awards for balancing extreme heat with real flavor. Reach for it when "instant regret" is exactly the experience you want.

Flavor & Heat Profile

  • Heat / Scoville: An estimated ~800,000 SHU* — extreme
  • Peppers: 50% blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion
  • Taste: Bold, pepper-forward heat with lasting burn and real flavor
  • Size: 5 fl oz bottle

How to Use It

Add Xtreme Regret a few drops at a time to wings, tacos, chili, ramen, or eggs when you want genuine instant-regret heat. As a Carolina Reaper hot sauce built on a real pepper blend, it brings flavor along with the fire — but treat an estimated ~800,000 SHU* with respect and build up slowly.

Why You'll Love It

  • True Carolina Reaper hot sauce at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*
  • 50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion
  • 9x award winner for heat and flavor
  • Instant-regret heat that still tastes like peppers, not extract
  • Non-GMO, gluten-free, and vegan
  • Nut-free, soy-free, and dairy-free
  • From a 63x award-winning brand

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Xtreme Regret Scoville rating? How hot is it?

Xtreme Regret comes in at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*, powered by a 50% pepper blend of Carolina Reaper and Trinidad Scorpion. That makes this carolina reaper hot sauce genuinely extreme — true instant-regret territory — while keeping the bold pepper flavor that extract-based sauces lack. Start with one or two drops.

Is Xtreme Regret a real Carolina Reaper sauce?

Yes. Xtreme Regret is built on a 50% pepper blend featuring Carolina Reaper alongside Trinidad Scorpion, so it is a true carolina reaper sauce rather than a flavored extract. The result is an estimated ~800,000 SHU* of bold, pepper-forward heat that has earned 9 awards for balancing fire with flavor.

Why is it called instant regret hot sauce?

The name fits the experience: at an estimated ~800,000 SHU*, Xtreme Regret delivers fast, intense Carolina Reaper heat that lingers. It is the kind of instant regret hot sauce chiliheads chase — but because it is a real 50% pepper blend, the regret comes with genuine flavor, not just punishment.

*SHU is estimated based on the percentage of peppers used.

Why Buy American

Why Americans Buy From Us

100% American Made

Every product on our site is sourced, crafted, and shipped from within the United States. No exceptions.

No Tariff Markups

Our supply chain never leaves the country. That means no surprise costs passed on to you.

American Jobs, American Families

Every purchase puts money directly into the hands of American workers, small businesses, and family-run shops.

Join the Movement

Stay in the loop

Get updates on American-made products, maker stories, and new drops.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.