Skip to content

GET UPDATES ON AMERICAN-MADE PRODUCTS & NEW DROPS

Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Amish Country Store

Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz

$9.50 Sale
Size: 20 oz
Quantity
American Made Guarantee
Ships From the USA
Supports American Business
Shipping & returns

Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.

Why American-made

Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.

Enjoy the smooth, sweet flavor of McCutcheon’s Cherry Butter, a homestyle fruit butter made with cherries, sugar, vanilla extract, fruit pectin, and warm spices. This spreadable cherry favorite brings rich fruit flavor to toast, biscuits, pancakes, desserts, and everyday pantry treats.

With its soft texture and classic home recipe style, cherry butter is a simple way to add old-fashioned fruit flavor without the thicker pieces found in preserves. Choose the 9 oz jar for gifting, sampling, or smaller households, or the 20 oz jar for family breakfasts, baking, and frequent use.


Why You’ll Love It

  • Smooth cherry fruit butter with a sweet, rich flavor
  • Made with cherries, sugar, vanilla extract, fruit pectin, and spices
  • Available in both 9 oz and 20 oz jar sizes
  • Great for breakfast, desserts, baking, and thoughtful gifting

Best Ways to Enjoy

  • Spread over toast, biscuits, English muffins, bagels, or warm rolls
  • Spoon onto pancakes, waffles, French toast, oatmeal, or yogurt
  • Use as a topping for cheesecake, pound cake, ice cream, or dessert bars
  • Pair with cream cheese, brie, goat cheese, or sharp cheddar on a snack board
  • Swirl into thumbprint cookies, pastries, muffins, or homemade baked goods

Product Details

Product: Cherry Butter

Brand: McCutcheon’s

Available Sizes: 10 oz and 20 oz

Flavor Profile: Smooth cherry, sweet fruit butter, light vanilla, warm spice, and homestyle pantry character.

Ingredients: Cherries (red and black), sugar, citric acid, vanilla extract, fruit pectin, spices.

Storage: Refrigerate after opening.


Smooth, sweet, and easy to use, this Cherry Butter is a classic country pantry spread for breakfast tables, dessert plates, snack boards, and simple everyday treats.

Why Buy American

Why Americans Buy From Us

100% American Made

Every product on our site is sourced, crafted, and shipped from within the United States. No exceptions.

No Tariff Markups

Our supply chain never leaves the country. That means no surprise costs passed on to you.

American Jobs, American Families

Every purchase puts money directly into the hands of American workers, small businesses, and family-run shops.

Join the Movement

Stay in the loop

Get updates on American-made products, maker stories, and new drops.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.