Fudge: Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Gifts
Dark Chocolate Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Cookies 'n Cream Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Orange Cream Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Chocolate Walnut Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Pistachio Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Mint Chocolate Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
Butter Pecan Fudge – Handmade, 4 or 8 oz
-
Our sourcing standard Three tiers, stated plainly — including when a product is only partly made here.
-
Independent American makers Every listing traces to a named workshop you can look up.
-
Ships direct from the maker An order from several makers arrives in several boxes, each with its own shipping.
Collection Guide
Fudge: Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Gifts
Handmade Fudge Made in USA – Buy Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Specialty Fudge Online
Looking to buy fudge online? Discover American-made fudge from U.S. confectioners, with creamy chocolate classics, peanut butter fudge, maple and pecan favorites, salted caramel, cookies and cream, and specialty dessert-inspired flavors. Shop by flavor, compare recipes and select handmade fudge for a personal treat or a thoughtful gift.
Start with classic chocolate fudge, peanut butter fudge, dark chocolate fudge, chocolate walnut fudge, salted caramel fudge or cookies and cream fudge. The fudge assortment includes traditional recipes and inventive variations from several American fudge makers.
Every recipe and package is different. Check each fudge listing for net weight, ingredients, allergens, available options, shipping details and storage instructions before ordering.
Order Handmade Chocolate, Peanut Butter and Specialty Fudge Online
Our American-made fudge collection is dedicated to the confection itself. Compare classic chocolate fudge, dark chocolate fudge, creamy peanut butter fudge, chocolate walnut fudge, maple pecan fudge, salted caramel fudge and unique specialty flavors from makers across the United States.
Chocolate Fudge for Traditional Fudge Lovers
Find chocolate, milk chocolate, dark chocolate, chocolate chunk and espresso fudge, with options for those who prefer a classic smooth texture or a richer cocoa taste.
Nut Fudge, Maple Fudge and Caramel Fudge
Shop peanut butter, chocolate walnut, maple walnut, butter pecan, pistachio, chocolate caramel and salted caramel variations. Always verify nut ingredients and other allergen information.
Specialty Fudge and Fudge Gifts
Explore cookies and cream, cheesecake, cake batter, fruit-and-chocolate combinations, rocky road and seasonal-inspired fudge flavors. Compare available package options and order details for personal enjoyment or gifting.
Browse the fudge products above, choose your favorite flavor and shop American-made fudge directly at BuyAmerican.com.
Buy American. Build America.
Shop Fudge by Flavor: Find Your Favorite Handmade Fudge
Fudge is a rich, dense confection that may be creamy and smooth or include nuts, cookies, fruit, caramel or chocolate pieces. Choosing fudge by flavor helps you compare similar recipes while discovering new favorites.
Classic Chocolate, Milk Chocolate and Dark Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate fudge is a traditional favorite with a creamy texture and satisfying cocoa flavor. Shop milk chocolate fudge for a familiar chocolate taste, dark chocolate fudge for stronger cocoa notes or chocolate chunk fudge for added chocolate pieces. Coffee lovers can also explore espresso dark chocolate fudge.
Flavor intensity, sweetness, firmness and the actual chocolate ingredients vary between makers. Review the product description rather than assuming every chocolate fudge recipe is identical.
Peanut Butter Fudge and Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
For rich, nutty flavor, compare peanut butter fudge, Peanut Butter Explosion Fudge and chocolate peanut butter fudge. Choose a peanut butter-forward recipe or a combination of peanut butter and chocolate depending on the taste and texture you prefer.
Allergen note: Peanut butter fudge contains peanut ingredients. Other fudge may contain or come into contact with peanuts or other allergens; consult each product's ingredient and manufacturing information.
Chocolate Walnut, Maple Walnut and Pecan Fudge
Nut fudge brings a contrast between creamy candy and crunchy or tender nuts. Available options include chocolate walnut fudge, maple walnut fudge, butter pecan fudge and chocolate pecan fudge. For a different maple recipe, consider maple pecan fudge with real maple syrup, or try pistachio fudge.
Check the listed nut variety, recipe and allergen statement. If you prefer a smooth fudge without pieces, shop an appropriate plain chocolate or other flavor instead.
Salted Caramel, Chocolate Caramel and Turtle Fudge
Sweet and salty flavors meet a creamy fudge base in salted caramel fudge, chocolate caramel fudge and dark chocolate salted caramel fudge. Nut lovers may prefer turtle fudge, featuring a chocolate, caramel and pecan-inspired combination, or salted caramel cashew fudge.
Cookies and Cream, Cheesecake and Dessert-Inspired Fudge
Explore fudge that takes inspiration from familiar desserts, including cookies and cream fudge, red velvet cheesecake fudge, Biscoff cheesecake fudge, s'mores fudge, cake batter fudge with sprinkles and chocolate toffee fudge.
Cookie pieces, cheesecake flavors and dessert mix-ins can introduce milk, wheat, soy, nuts or other allergens. Read the full ingredient and allergen details for the individual flavor.
Fruit Fudge, Maple Fudge and Other Specialty Flavors
Try a different approach to classic fudge with chocolate strawberry fudge, dark chocolate cherry fudge, strawberry cheesecake fudge, orange cream fudge, maple fudge, penuche butterscotch fudge or maple walnut fudge.
How to Buy Fudge Online: Size, Ingredients, Delivery and Gifts
Compare Fudge by Weight and Package Contents
When shopping for handmade fudge online, use the listed package weight, piece count and product options to compare offers. A similar-looking product photo does not guarantee the same serving quantity. Review the specific selection at checkout, especially when purchasing several flavors.
Fudge Gifts for Birthdays, Holidays and Special Occasions
Fudge gifts are a sweet option for birthdays, thank-you gestures, holiday treats, care packages, family celebrations and dessert tables. Choose widely liked flavors such as chocolate and peanut butter, or a specialty variety that suits the recipient's taste. If buying several products, confirm whether each one has separate packaging, a gift-message option or special fulfillment requirements.
Do not assume a listing includes a gift box, multi-flavor sampler or personalized message unless it specifically says so.
Shipping Fudge and Warm-Weather Delivery
Fudge can be sensitive to high temperatures during transport, which may affect its shape, surface or texture. Shipping methods and protective packaging depend on the individual seller. Review warm-weather shipping policies, order processing times, shipping destinations and delivery instructions before ordering. If sending fudge as a gift, arrange for the recipient to bring the package inside soon after delivery.
How to Store Fudge After It Arrives
Storage requirements differ by recipe. Some fudge can be kept in a cool, dry location for a period specified by the maker; other fudge containing perishable fillings or ingredients may require refrigeration. Follow the product's actual package label and storage instructions, not a general shelf-life estimate for all fudge. Avoid excessive heat, sunlight and humidity, and keep opened fudge covered as directed.
Food Allergens, Gluten-Free Claims and Ingredient Labels
Fudge recipes may contain milk, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy or other allergens. Cross-contact is possible when different flavors share production equipment. Read the product's ingredient and allergen information in full before purchasing. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration's guide to reading allergen labels explains what packaged-food shoppers should check.
One specific product in this collection is labeled Gluten Free Cookies and Cream Fudge. Do not extend that claim to any other fudge listed here or assume a product is dairy-free, vegan, nut-free or sugar-free without maker confirmation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fudge
Where can I buy American-made fudge online?
BuyAmerican.com offers fudge from American confectioners, including chocolate, peanut butter, maple, caramel, nut, fruit and dessert-inspired flavors. Review individual products for manufacturing, ingredient and delivery details.
What is handmade fudge?
Fudge is a dense, usually soft confection made by combining sweeteners with chocolate, dairy or another creamy base and flavorings. Handmade recipes vary in texture, ingredients and preparation.
What fudge flavors are available?
Current options include chocolate, milk chocolate, dark chocolate, chocolate walnut, peanut butter, maple walnut, pecan, pistachio, salted caramel, cookies and cream, cheesecake and numerous specialty flavors.
Do you have chocolate peanut butter fudge?
Yes. The assortment includes chocolate peanut butter fudge as well as classic peanut butter fudge and other peanut-butter-forward recipes. Check the particular product for peanuts and other allergens.
Can I send fudge as a gift?
Yes. Fudge can be ordered for a recipient when the product and shipping options allow. Review packaging, delivery timing, shipping destinations and available gift features before checkout.
Does fudge need to be refrigerated?
It depends on the recipe. Follow the specific manufacturer's storage instructions, especially for fudge containing perishable dairy or fruit-based ingredients.
How long does fudge stay fresh?
Shelf life depends on ingredients, packaging, handling and temperature. Use the manufacturer's freshness and date guidance for the exact product you receive.
Can I order fudge in warm weather?
Shipping options differ by maker and destination. Check the listing's heat protection or warm-weather shipping instructions because high temperatures can affect fudge during delivery.
Is there gluten-free fudge in the collection?
One listing is specifically labeled Gluten Free Cookies and Cream Fudge. Read its complete ingredient and allergen disclosures; not all fudge here is gluten-free.
What is the difference between maple fudge and maple walnut fudge?
Maple fudge emphasizes maple flavor, while maple walnut fudge also includes walnuts for added taste and texture. Recipe and ingredient details vary among makers.
Are all fudge ingredients grown or sourced in the USA?
Not necessarily. American-made fudge may use some imported ingredients. Read each seller's product-level manufacturing and sourcing disclosures if the origin of every ingredient matters to you.
