100% American Made
Every product on our site is sourced, crafted, and shipped from within the United States. No exceptions.
Let's Get Baked Artisan Desserts
Fluffernutter Cookies – Peanut Butter & Marshmallow
$16.00
Quantity
American Made Guarantee
Ships From the USA
Supports American Business
Shipping & returns
Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.
Product Details
Bring back a nostalgic favorite with these Fluffernutter Cookies—classic peanut butter cookies stuffed with sweet marshmallow fluff. Each generous 4 oz cookie combines rich peanut butter flavor with a gooey marshmallow center for the familiar sweet-and-salty taste of a traditional fluffernutter in dessert form.
Made in the USA and available in 4-, 6-, or 12-count packages, these peanut butter marshmallow cookies are a fun choice for dessert, gifting, care packages, parties, or simply keeping a few indulgent treats on hand.
Peanut Butter & Marshmallow Fluffernutter Cookies
The traditional fluffernutter pairs peanut butter and marshmallow fluff. These cookies take that classic combination and turn it into a bakery-style treat, starting with a peanut butter cookie and adding marshmallow fluff inside.
- Cookie size: 4 oz each
- Flavor: Peanut butter and marshmallow fluff
- Available quantities: 4-count, 6-count, or 12-count
- Made in: USA
- Great for: Dessert, gifts, care packages, parties, and sharing
A Nostalgic American Dessert
If you love peanut butter cookies, marshmallow treats, or the classic fluffernutter sandwich, this cookie delivers those familiar flavors in a substantial 4 oz dessert. Choose the pack size that works best for treating yourself, sharing with family and friends, or sending as a sweet gift.
Allergen Information
Contains nut, soy, wheat, and milk products. Customers with food allergies or dietary restrictions should review the product label and current manufacturer-provided allergen information before consuming.
Looking for more treats made by American businesses? Explore our American-made food and pantry collection for baked goods, sweets, snacks, and other specialty foods.
Why American-made
Share shipping times, return policy, or product details here. You can also connect this to a product metafield with the dynamic source icon.
Bring back a nostalgic favorite with these Fluffernutter Cookies—classic peanut butter cookies stuffed with sweet marshmallow fluff. Each generous 4 oz cookie combines rich peanut butter flavor with a gooey marshmallow center for the familiar sweet-and-salty taste of a traditional fluffernutter in dessert form.
Made in the USA and available in 4-, 6-, or 12-count packages, these peanut butter marshmallow cookies are a fun choice for dessert, gifting, care packages, parties, or simply keeping a few indulgent treats on hand.
Peanut Butter & Marshmallow Fluffernutter Cookies
The traditional fluffernutter pairs peanut butter and marshmallow fluff. These cookies take that classic combination and turn it into a bakery-style treat, starting with a peanut butter cookie and adding marshmallow fluff inside.
- Cookie size: 4 oz each
- Flavor: Peanut butter and marshmallow fluff
- Available quantities: 4-count, 6-count, or 12-count
- Made in: USA
- Great for: Dessert, gifts, care packages, parties, and sharing
A Nostalgic American Dessert
If you love peanut butter cookies, marshmallow treats, or the classic fluffernutter sandwich, this cookie delivers those familiar flavors in a substantial 4 oz dessert. Choose the pack size that works best for treating yourself, sharing with family and friends, or sending as a sweet gift.
Allergen Information
Contains nut, soy, wheat, and milk products. Customers with food allergies or dietary restrictions should review the product label and current manufacturer-provided allergen information before consuming.
Looking for more treats made by American businesses? Explore our American-made food and pantry collection for baked goods, sweets, snacks, and other specialty foods.
Keep exploring
More American-Made Picks
Sale
The Military Gift Store
Burial/Funeral Flag Display Case Frame, Military Shadow Box with Pedestal Stand - Cherry
$345.99
$445.99
Sale
The Military Gift Store
Flag Display Cases, Burial Flag Display Case solid cherry, hand crafted flag case
$225.99
$269.00
Why Buy American
Why Americans Buy From Us
No Tariff Markups
Our supply chain never leaves the country. That means no surprise costs passed on to you.
American Jobs, American Families
Every purchase puts money directly into the hands of American workers, small businesses, and family-run shops.
Join the Movement
Stay in the loop
Get updates on American-made products, maker stories, and new drops.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
