Skip to content

Every listing traced to a U.S. maker

Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter package with serving suggestions in a styled food scene
Miller’s apple butter ingredient and Lamoni, Iowa production label on 18 oz jar
Back of a Miller’s apple butter jar
Miller’s apple butter ingredient and Lamoni, Iowa production label on 18 oz jar
Miller’s apple butter ingredient and Lamoni, Iowa production label on 9.4 oz jar

Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter | 18 oz & 9.4 oz

$8.75 Sale
Size: 18oz
Quantity
Ships direct from the workshop that made it
Most items dispatch in 1–2 business days, then 3–5 days in transit. An order covering more than one workshop arrives as separate parcels, each with its own shipping — your full shipping total is shown at checkout.
Sourcing stated plainly
Verified American-made
Ships direct from the shop
Details

Amish Country Store identifies siblings Jeremy Sellars and Jennifer Warrington as the founders of its family business, established in 2009 in Lamoni, Iowa. What began as a roadside welcome center grew into a marketplace for regional food and handmade goods. Its mission centers on supporting Amish artisans, local makers, and the families who carry on rural Iowa’s craft traditions.

Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter

Miller’s Apple Butter is a slow-cooked apple spread made by a local Amish family. The supplier describes a smooth texture and explicitly states that this variety is made in the USA. The two size-label photographs differ on cinnamon; see the ingredient section for that detail. Serve it with warm biscuits, spoon a little onto oatmeal, or choose it as an apple spread for your next breakfast table.

The package choice is 18 oz & 9.4 oz.

Browse Fruit Butters to compare other flavors and package choices at BuyAmerican.com.

Explore the store’s regional craft traditions in Iowa PBS’s profile of Amish Country Store in Lamoni.

Features

Ways to Enjoy This Variety

  • Spread on toast or a warm biscuit.
  • Offer a small dish with cheese and crackers.
  • Spoon over yogurt, oatmeal, or a finished dessert.
Specifications

Product and Package Details

  • Product: Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter
  • Supplier: Amish Country Store, Lamoni, Iowa
  • Package contents: 18 oz & 9.4 oz
  • Country of manufacture: United States.
Materials
Care

Storage and Handling

Refrigerate after opening. Use a clean utensil when portioning the product and follow all directions on the received package. Keep its label available for the ingredient list, best-by information, and any preparation instructions. Storage directions can differ among varieties, so follow this item’s own instructions rather than those on another product.

Shipping & returns

Shipping and Returns for This Food Product

Shipping

Amish Country Store ships from southern Iowa. In-stock items typically dispatch within 1–3 business days, Monday through Friday; holidays and busy periods can extend processing. Standard transit is usually 2–7 business days after dispatch and is an estimate, not a delivery guarantee. Shipping charges depend on destination, package dimensions and weight, and service. Checkout determines the charges applicable to your BuyAmerican order; no supplier free-shipping offer was verified.

Returns and Delivery Damage

The supplier excludes food from returns. Its 30-day return period, $7.50 return-label fee, and 10% restocking fee apply only to eligible non-food items, not this food product. Inspect delivery promptly and report damage within 48 hours, with photographs of the product, packaging, and shipping label. Contact BuyAmerican about a marketplace order so the issue can be coordinated with the supplier. Do not send an item back without authorization.

Why this is American-made

Made to our sourcing standard

Every listing is traced to a U.S. workshop before it goes live. Our standard has three tiers, and we state plainly which one applies, including when a product is only partly made here.

  • Our sourcing standard Three tiers, stated plainly, including when a product is only partly made here.
  • Independent American makers Every listing is traced to a U.S. workshop before it goes live.
  • Ships direct from the maker An order from several workshops arrives in several boxes, each with its own shipping.